O’Toole Scrivo represents a wide variety of clients appealing from civil and criminal matters. Our appellate lawyers are critical thinkers and skilled oral advocates, and we understand the need for vigorous and persuasive brief writing to advance our clients’ appeals.
O’Toole Scrivo has an impressive track record of successfully defending favorable trial rulings and overturning adverse decisions in complex matters. Our attorneys are adept at beginning to identify appellate issues during the trial phase so that, if an appeal becomes necessary, appellate issues have been identified and evaluated, and our clients are able to make informed decisions on whether to appeal.
We also have extensive experience assisting clients who seek our help at the appellate stage. Whether prosecuting or defending a merits appeal, filing appellate motions, or representing an amicus curiae, our appellate attorneys understand how to immerse themselves in the record and bring a fresh perspective to bear on our clients’ needs.
O’Toole Scrivo’s appellate practice primarily focuses on appeals to the Second and Third Circuit Courts of Appeal, and the appellate courts of New Jersey and New York.


Anthony D. Capasso Partner
(973) 559-9805
David M. Chaise Associate
(973) 559-9808
Casey Chamra Partner
(973) 559-9809
Craig J. Compoli Partner
(973) 559-9811
Lawrence S. Cutalo Partner
(973) 559-9812
Alex R. Daniel Of Counsel
(973) 559-9827
Nicole M. DeMuro Of Counsel
(973) 559-9814
Michael J. Dee Partner
(973) 559-9813
Maggie Delany Associate
(973) 559-9826
James DiGiulio Partner
(973) 559-9815
Julia E. Duffy Associate
(973) 559-9856
R. Brant Forrest Of Counsel
(973) 559-9818
Alexandra V. Gallo Partner
(973) 559-9820
Robert J. Gallop Partner
(973) 559-9821
Robert W. Gifford Partner
(973) 559-9823
Kenneth B. Goodman Associate
(973) 559-9825
Larry C. Green, Jr. Of Counsel
(973) 559-9852
Peter V. Koenig Of Counsel
(973) 559-9831
Joseph J. McGlone Partner
(973) 559-9836
Stephanie Mishler Associate
(973) 559-9839
Joseph A. Natale Associate
(973) 559-9855
Amy Robinson Of Counsel
(973) 559-9833
German Rozencranc Of Counsel
(973) 559-9842
Thomas P. Scrivo Managing Partner
(973) 559-9900
Marlin G. Townes Of Counsel
(973) 559-9844
Cassandra Jahnke Walsh Associate
(973) 559-9829
Nicholas P. Whittaker Associate
(973) 559-9830
Young Yu Of Counsel
(973) 559-9849
Jia Zhang Associate
(973) 559-9861
Joshua A. Zielinski Partner
(973) 559-9851On October 22, 2021, the New Jersey Appellate Division issued a far-reaching decision in Youssef v. …
In Baldwin Shields v. Ramslee Motors, the Supreme Court of New Jersey recently considered whether the owner of a commercial property has a duty to clear ice and snow from its premises when the property is in the exclusive possession of a tenant.